I was going to order this from CIP-1 as suggested by someone on The Samba,
however, on CIP-1 the part was $6 but shipping was $10! So I ebayed it on up and saved a few bucks for the same thing. And may have found a new parts supplier in the process.

Update: Within moments of ordering this part, I saw that the seller had one listed for my model of Bus as well (notice it says for the Bug on the screenshot above), so I sent him a message asking if the two parts were the same, and if not, could he please send me the one for the Bus instead. Moments after I sent that message, I saw on my invoice that my shipping address was 2 years outdated and I no longer lived in that part of the state, let alone at that address. So I sent the seller another message asking to send it to my current address. We will see if either of these requests are granted. What a n00b.